Wednesday, April 13, 2011
Greg Albin: Crossing the Color Line
1.) What do you think of the move toward implicature?
2.) Do you believe that it is altogether possible to reframe society from merely empathy to implicature?
Ch 36: Crossing the color line - Tom Cameron
Crossing the Color Line-Katrina
This week’s reading started with a discussion of the definition of empathy. I really enjoyed hearing how different scholars have come to define the word. It’s interesting to see how the idea of empathy has evolved over time to where it is now. While the reading didn’t explicitly address it, the different between sympathy and empathy becomes every so clear in that empathy involves “feeling with” rather than “feeling for.”
Dace’s concludes her writing stating “empathy may just be the key.” Personally I feel that this is critical to any relationship. Keeping this in mind, empathy play a part in explaining why we (people) tend to gravitate towards people they share commonalities with or who we consider similar to us. It is not essential to have experienced the same situation as someone to be empathic towards them. Empathy can be achieved by reflecting on a situation that involved similar emotions. However, empathize comes far more naturally when you have experienced firsthand what someone else is going through. For the same reason, empathize with someone who has drastically different life experience than you own could be challenging. Knowing empathy is a crucial component of developing relationship, I would make an argument that we are attracted to those similar to us because it is easier to empathize with them; the relationship progresses faster and with greater ease.
I’m always surprised when people give so much attention to the diversity of their contacts (in turns of race and ethnicity). I can honestly say race has never been a point meriting specific recognition. This is not to say I’m not interested who they are and where they’ve come from but rather I’ve never define someone as their race. I focus on describing them by their personality, character, and interests. It’s hard for me to grasp why skin color merits so much attention from both the majority and minorities. I know when you are in the minority you are more sensitive to the majority. Trying to emphasize, I tried to come up with a situation(s) in which I was in the minority and made conscious mental notes about it. Two examples came to mind (1) classes that were male dominated and (2) situations in which I was the non-native speaker. Thinking back to these help me relate and understand the notion of viewing from aspects far more superficial than character and personality. In both those situations, nothing was really changed about the potential to form relationship but I’m sure in some aspects it had an impact on how I communicated.
(1) When do you find it easiest to empathize? And most difficult?
(2) How can we further develop our ability to empathize with others?
Crossing the Color line
The quote by Nathan McCall makes me laugh when he says that," Its sad, this gulf between blacks and whites. We're so afraid of each other." Afraid? Ive never been afraid my Black friends just like they aren't afraid of me as a White person. I think if people stepped out of the box and realize that respecting each other goes a long way to breaking a color line. So what if somebody is a different color or different ethnicity than you? Its skin color, if you take away skin there isn't anything different inside. Its like what the ol' saying goes" Dont judge a book by its cover."
1. Do different up bringings affect a person's outlook on issues? Such as race?
2. When will people realize that the color of a person's skin doesn't matter?
Crossing the Color Line
Crossing the Color Line - Dylan Goodell
I believe this article shows that we should put ourselves out there and ask those random and hard to ask questions to our friends of different races. Sure it's probably going to be hard to just bring it up out of the blue but if we ask these kind of questions we can learn a lot more about each other and understand each other better. In the end it should make everyone understand each other better and strengthen our relationships with future friends.
1. Do you believe that it might have been partially McCall's fault that Danny was the first person that he met that actually cared?
2. After reading this article will you ask these kind of curious questions to your friends of a different race? or do you think it would hurt your friendship?
Crossing The Color Line - Nico Bohm
The thing that stuck out the most to me in Crossing the Color Line was how much the authors talked about empathy. The first definition was “the inner world of private personal meanings as if it were your own, but without ever losing the as if quality”. To me this means, we need to respect each other’s differences. We are all from different parts of this country (and world) and no two people are exactly the same. We need to be empathetic towards each other. Another definition of empathy that jumped out to me was, “a qualitative, developmental process in which individuals not only come to share and understand another’s feelings but also consider the reasons and context that inform the other’s feeling”. This makes a bit more sense to me. I really think the most important part is being able to understand each other’s feelings and hence, setting boundaries to make sure everyone stays happy.
One final part of this essay that caught my attention was when the author said Blacks and Whites are afraid of each other. I mean, there are differences between the two groups, but I wouldn’t call it a fear. Some people who give into stereotypes may fear crossing a black man in a dark alley, but I think that is more fear of a stereotype than fear of an entire race. I could pass a black man in an alley and be cautious, but in turn pass one in the middle of the day downtown and not even notice him. I would be interested to hear this from a black point of view.
1. Do you think blacks fear whites or vice versa?
2. What does empathy mean to you?
3. What advances have we made in erasing the color line and how much is left?
Crossing the Color Line - Brian Elsasser
I found it entertaining when the author mentioned the 3 types of personalities. One been the type that understands and can talk about anything with anyone including race issues. Two being the "guilty liberal" (my favorite) those whites that try so hard to relate with blacks that they feel more pity for their oppression than understanding their culture. And finally those who can be friends and talk with blacks about most anything other than the race issue. I am not positive that there are only the 3 types of personality but it is an entertaining thought.
One thing that I am glad was brought up in this chapter was when he mentions a white friend of his saying that he should give more white people a chance and that he may be pleasantly surprised, meaning that not every white person is racist. I have run into experiences with a few black friends who every time they meet a white person they automatically assume he is a racist, I have always found this interesting as it parallels the some whites attitudes about the black stereotype. In that making those first assumptions you are automatically seeing that person in a worst light and then that person has little chance to win you over.
The last thing I want to mention is at one point it is brought up by the black author that he is often angry and that that anger stems from he racism he deals with everyday. "The black male as inherently angry" is a stereotype that we discussed in previous chapters and I do not believe this proves the stereotype. It is not an excuse but it does bring to light that black men sometimes struggle with a constant shadow of prejudice hanging over them.
Crossing the Color Line
While I didn't really get to experience much as far as different backgrounds and cultures as a child, I did get a few chances to go on trips with my church were we helped kids and families who were living in the inner cities. It was a real eye opening experience every time we went because we got to experience how they lived their life and how it was so much different from ours. The children we came into contact with acted just the same as I did and just about every other kid growing up, all they wanted to do was play and have fun. But the adults on the other hand knew they were living a tough life and it was hard for them to get by from day to day. just because they were from a different ethnic background or grew up less fortunate than someone else didnt mean they were not going to have the best life they possibly could.
Questions:
1. How has the color line helped shape the culture and society we live in today?
2. What would our culture look like today if there was even some sort of color line still around?
Crossing The Color Line - Tate
Herink - COLOR LINE
Ch. 36 Crossing the Color Line, Tylor Robinson
Crossing the Color Line Sarah Harvey
The article reiterates the point of empathy, and the author gives us a variation of definitions of the term. I agree with the article on how we should learn and accept differences in people. In my opinion I think it is incredibly false when people say that they don’t see color or ethnicity, because we all notice these differences in people lets be honest. I don’t think there is anything wrong with learning and experiencing the differences of the people that surround us. It is better to learn and accept instead of just ignore and forget about others. Communication is the largest issue that hold people back in this integral part of learning about other people, it seems there is a fear of the unknown, and so instead of trying to talk and learn, we mainly just pretend we don’t see what is really there.
This article just really pushes the envelope for pushing past our stereotypes and boundaries, in order to learn about others and in essence ourselves as well. It is clear that none of us are colorblind, and rather than pretend we are, lets put our differences to great use and further educate one another.
1. It is easy to say we need to see past the color line, but do you think you would randomly discuss this subject with someone of another race, without the context of this article?
2. Do you remember noticing the differences between people as a child, if so how old were you when you started to notice differences and similarities?
3. How does empathy play a role in everyday life for those who have not read this article?
Ch. 36 Crossing the Color Line
Sarah Milem - Crossing the Color Line
Periago Jessica – Crossing the Color Line – Chapter 36
The first part of the article focuses mainly on empathy. The author gives us a variety of definitions regarding this term. The one that I like the most is “empathy encourages individuals to respect and appreciate cultural differences instead of simply erasing or ignoring them, and encourages communication that is nonjudgmental and accepting of others.” The most important part of this quote is "encourages communication". I think people need to express what they think without having the fear of being judged by their audience. In return, the audience should not judge the person who is talking but instead try to understand the message that she is trying to convey. At this point, both sides can have a constructive conversation.
Race always has been a big issue, especially between people of different color. This is emphasized by the fact that on both sides it is taboo to talk about race and culture. I can’t imagine how frustrated this can be for the people who actually try to step out of their comfort zone and are willing to understand what is happening on the other side of the “Line”. I am glad that there is more and more people like Bill who try to do the right thing without thinking that they “deserve a medal” for what they are accomplishing. Karen brought up a good point when she said that she developed friendships where people “feel comfortable enough to ask uncomfortable questions.” I think this is the way people should approach this race and culture issue and also be more open-minded.
The message that comes out of this text is that people of both sides of “The Color Line” need to first show empathy to one another. Second, try to be implicate with one another, when people would reach that step then the relationship between people of color will be able to get better.
Questions:
1. When someone talks to you about his or her problems do you always show them your full attention, empathy and really try to help them feel better?
2. Would you admit and address your fear about people that are different from you to any of your friends?
3. Would you feel comfortable enough to ask uncomfortable question to someone from another color?
4. What are some of the barriers between races?
Ch. 36 Crossing the Color Line
One of the main ideas they talk about to help us look past race to communicate with people with out prejudice is true empathy. The define empathy as the ability to understand another’s “inner world of private personal meanings as if it were your own, but without ever losing the ‘as if’ quality” of the experience. It is basically telling us not to judge with your pre-conceived stereotypes and to try to understand them as a person and who they truly are. I believe this is useful in every type of communication with whomever it may be. This is the only way around prejudice. Everybody comes from different cultures but they should be seen for who they truly are rather than their culture. They talk about how Bill volunteered how he did because he truly empathized with the children and enjoyed it. He didn’t do it for the publicity or to look good he did it because he enjoyed it. Also, McCall speaks how Danny asked many questions that most whites wouldn’t but didn’t fear being labeled a racist and McCall concluded that it was because Danny was secure in his mind that he wasn’t a racist and had nothing to hide. He was simply just curious.
People need to not be afraid of one another and see past the stereotypes. They must empathize with others and recognize who they are rather than make communication a battle. They must use empathy to acknowledge the psychological and implicature to acknowledge the physical. Everyone is different and we must see that in our communication.
1. Are race issues simply built solely out of fear?
2. Once labeled a racist by one of the opposite race is it possible to overcome the label that is already built inside themselves even with empathy?
Tuesday, April 12, 2011
Crossing the Color Line
In this reading, the overall message that I received was that of mutual self-consciousness in regard to relationships with the “other” race. The main races addressed were African American and European American. Each main idea was either the appearance of unease in the company of the other race or the small ideas that could help bridge the cultural gap.
One point in particular, the author identified 3 types of friends. The one type of friend, personally I would consider more of an acquaintance, was deemed the “guilty liberal”. They are the worst kind in my eyes, and not worst as in they actively do harm to a minority group, but their belief creates this entitlement for the minority group in a reverse racism way. Ultimately saying, this should make up for things that unjustly happened many years ago. They are hurting themselves and dampening our ability to move forward. Maybe I’m the only that feels that way though.
I did like the portion that drew attention to Bill’s coaching and his indifference to whether it was acknowledged or not. Those people are the kind that can truly bridge any cultural void. They don’t see a group that needs to be coddled into a safe environment. They see individuals and people that they can offer a service to, not to be praised for their action, but out of genuine concern. I=
Discussion Questions
When evaluating your interracial friendships, is the first thing to come to mind your differences or similarities?
Would you consider someone, that you have to censor yourself around, a true friend?
Monday, April 4, 2011
Performing Commitment - Nico Bohm
I did a project in high school about gay marriage so I feel I can relate to this article very well. Normally, I see myself for gay marriage. I feel if two people love each other, they should be together. Who are we to say someone can’t be with the person they love? Plus, people need the benefits of marriage. I didn’t really understand where Jackie was going with her article before I figured out she was gay, then I realized why she was analyzing wedding so closely. I think it was good that she had a “wedding” for her close friends and family. In different relationships such as these, the more normal things remain, the better.
One thing I am not sure of is adopting children. I have read studies that say children come out just fine and are not changed at all. Them being raised gay is a myth. I don’t think gay parents would want their children to grow up without a choice. There are plenty of places that a child can grow up that would be detrimental to their health, but a same sex parent family is not one of them. If they were loved and in a stable household they could easily grow up to be a great member of society. Jackie does speak about this when she says she believes a same sex family would be better off raising a child than a family that is fighting or breaking up.
1. What are your thoughts on same sex marriage?
2. Do you think same sex children will turn out the same as other children?